When Incompetence Meets Inevitability

5 thoughts from the perspective of a Commanders fan

1. May Jerry Live Forever

I hope Jerry lives to be 200 years old. I say this with all the sarcasm of a lifelong Commanders fan: thank you, Jerry. For decades, he’s run the Cowboys like a family business where he’s CEO, GM, and self-appointed football genius. Every once in a while, that works out. But more often than not, it ends like this — with a franchise cornerstone walking out the door because Jerry boxed himself in.


2. From Snyder’s Circus to Peters’ Boardroom

Before there were adults in the room, we had Dan Snyder — chaos, scandals, and a franchise run like a vanity project. Sound familiar, Dallas?

The difference now is night and day. Take Terry McLaurin’s extension. Negotiations got tense, sure, but it was professional. McLaurin’s agent Buddy Baker opened with an unrealistic ask. Peters drew a hard line, and eventually both sides landed on a deal that worked. Yes, it dragged out. At times it felt bleak. But it got done.

The Commanders finally have adults in the room, and you can see the difference already. Peters is building depth. He’s setting timelines. He’s treating roster construction like a business. One side operates with structure and strategy. The other side runs on… crazy.


3. The Days of Yore

When Jerry bought the Cowboys for $150 million, it was done with “a handshake and a look in the eye.” I’m sure that makes a great campfire story, but this isn’t 1989, and Micah Parsons isn’t a herd of cattle. This is a $200 million contract negotiation in a billion-dollar industry.

To bypass Micah’s agent, get offended when the “deal” didn’t get signed, and then act shocked that the player wanted representation involved — that’s malpractice.

You wouldn’t buy a Fortune 500 company without lawyers. You wouldn’t even buy a condo without contracts. Yet Jerry thought he could bypass the entire process and lock down a generational talent with a wink and a nod.


4. Inevitable, but Self-Inflicted

The Parsons trade didn’t happen in a vacuum — it was the culmination of years of mismanagement. Jerry slow-played Dak Prescott’s extension and ended up overpaying. Same story with CeeDee Lamb. Add Parsons to that equation and suddenly three players were eating over half the cap. Something had to give.

But the real cost of that mismanagement shows up in free agency. While other teams made moves, Dallas did next to nothing. And it’s not because players didn’t want to come — Derrick Henry practically begged to put on the star before signing with the Ravens. A competent GM with a capologist on staff could have staggered those extensions, front-loaded or back-loaded the deals, and created enough flexibility to bring in Henry — and still have room for another impact piece. Instead, the Cowboys were hamstrung.

And the timing only made it worse. Jerry could have seen the writing on the wall months ago. If he’d moved Parsons back in February, when half the league was flush with cap space and before it was obvious Dallas couldn’t pay him, he might have sparked a true bidding war. Multiple teams were ready to pay above market. The Cowboys got a return, sure, but not the kind of historic Herschel Walker-like haul Parsons should have commanded.

That’s the difference between being proactive and being reactive. Smart front offices build a long-term plan and keep optionality alive. Jerry Jones plays it year to year and wonders why he runs out of room. Losing Parsons wasn’t just a surprise. It was inevitable. And the cruelest part? It could have been completely avoided.


5. When Hatred Turns Into Pity, You’ve Hit Rock Bottom

Here’s the part I never thought I’d say: I actually feel sorry for Dallas.

I’ve always hated the Cowboys — it’s in my DNA. That animosity is pure. It’s simple. It’s one of the last great constants in life. Hatred is one thing… but pity? That’s worse.

Think about it. First, the Mavericks botch the Luka Doncic trade — a mistake that will haunt that franchise for decades. Now the Cowboys fumble Micah Parsons, the best defensive player they’ve drafted since DeMarcus Ware.

And that’s the ultimate humiliation. Because when your rivals stop spitting venom and start patting you on the head with pity, that’s when you’ve really lost. You don’t just become a rival anymore. You become a cautionary tale.

And pity, Jerry, is the one thing no Commanders fan ever thought we’d feel for Dallas.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Burgundy

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading